Knowledgebase

How Anti-Money Laundering Efforts Combat Human Trafficking

money laundering human trafficking

Human trafficking is the criminal trade of men, women and children for the purposes of commercial sex, forced labor or other forms of exploitation. There are currently over 40.3 million global victims of human trafficking, and according to the recent FATF report, Financial Flows from Human Trafficking, the aggregated criminal proceeds of human trafficking reached $150 billion in 2018. The potential to generate such sizeable financial returns makes human trafficking a common predicate crime for money laundering. 

The proximity between human trafficking and money laundering means that financial instituions play an important role in its detection and prevention. Effective AML programs can help firms identify traffickers and alert the authorities, but it is vital that those firms understand the challenges they face and how to deal with them.

What is Human Trafficking?

Human trafficking takes numerous forms; however, its victims are normally recruited by coercion, fraud, or force and then exploited on an ongoing basis for profit. In order to exploit their victims, traffickers often move them between locations or across international borders. The FATF’s 2018 report identifies three categories of human trafficking: 

  • Human trafficking for sexual exploitation: Victims forced into prostitution over an extended period of time.
  • Human trafficking for forced labor: Victims forced to provide free or extremely low-paid labor for traffickers in manual-labor roles, such as construction or farming.
  • Human trafficking for the removal of organs: Victims paid, coerced or even tricked into having organs removed for the profit of traffickers.

How Does Human Trafficking Relate to Money Laundering?

Perpetrators of human trafficking must transform their financial proceeds into legitimate funds through money laundering. However, because the financial flows from human trafficking are so diverse, detecting attempts to launder proceeds can be challenging. Regulatory authorities issue guidance on a range of financial red flags to help firms better position their AML programs to detect human trafficking.

These red flag indicators include:

  • Large deposits of money into accounts which are then immediately withdrawn in towns close to international borders.
  • Patterns of card transactions in even amounts of money between 10pm and 6am. 
  • Multiple victims sharing bank account information, e.g., phone number or address.
  • Sudden deviations from expected customer account activity.
  • Use of anonymous financial instruments to pay bills.
  • Structured deposits across multiple physical banking locations.

More specific indicators of human trafficking converge around the type of trafficking involved:

Sexual Exploitation: Traffickers often have to meet the basic welfare needs of sexual exploitation victims, providing things like food, accommodation and transport. In this type of trafficking, financial flows may be directed through victims or through the traffickers and money launderers themselves. 

Victims of human trafficking for sexual exploitation may:

  • Incur ongoing excessive expenses for food, transport and accommodation.
  • Conduct transactions excessively in virtual currencies or via international email money transfers.
  • Use mobile phone numbers which match escort service advertisements. 
  • Have bank accounts that are funded excessively by third-party cash deposits and that are not consistent with their level of wealth.

Similarly, perpetrators of trafficking for sexual exploitation may:

  • Spend money on websites linked with human trafficking.
  • Regularly make cash deposits using ATMs in bank branches.
  • Accompany and exert control over another person making cash deposits in a bank.

Forced Labor: Victims of human trafficking are often recruited by traffickers with the incentive of better or higher-paid jobs overseas. After recruitment, victims are forced into work through violence and intimidation, the restriction of identity papers or threats of exposure to immigration officials. Some forms of forced labor are classified as modern slavery since the victims receive little to no payment in return for their work.

Potential indicators of money laundering linked to forced labor include:

  • A single account being used to pay wages to multiple employees.
  • Wages deposited into an account then quickly withdrawn or transferred to a different account.
  • An individual who demonstrates control of another individual’s financial affairs and official documents when interacting with government or regulatory authorities.

Organ Removal: Human trafficking for the purposes of organ removal often requires an elaborate logistical and financial infrastructure, involving multiple parties and even medical services. The FATF acknowledges that human trafficking for organ removal is a less common form of the crime but nonetheless causes serious harm to its victims. 

Human trafficking for organ removal often generates two types of financial flow:

  • Infrastructure funds for organ removal. This may include arranging for medical facilities and equipment outside of accredited medical contexts.
  • Funds to pay individuals involved in the offense itself, including surgeons and other medical staff, and brokers who recruit victims and arrange logistics. 

Organ removal can provide significant one-time financial gains for traffickers: kidneys, for example, cost around $200,000 in certain markets. Firms should be alert to individuals, or networks of individuals, receiving sums of money which are not consistent with their current employment wages.

Human Trafficking and Anti-Money Laundering Best Practices

Financial institutions are in a unique position to prevent human trafficking by detecting traffickers’ attempts to launder their criminal proceeds. However, it is crucial that those institutions’ AML programs are set up appropriately in order to do so. Financial authorities around the world suggest AML best practices to help firms catch and prevent human traffickers attempting to launder money, these include:

  • Contextual information: Many indicators of human trafficking intersect with legitimate financial activities, often making the crime difficult to identify. With this in mind, firms should consider indicators in combination with as much contextual information as possible in order to make a more accurate determination.
  • Information sharing: When evaluating potential trafficking activity, firms should seek to share information to establish a more accurate picture of suspected trafficking operations. Many legislative frameworks include information sharing mechanisms that allow institutions to share information amongst themselves and with regulators.
  • Customer Due Diligence: Firms should enhance their efforts to identify trafficking by optimizing their Customer Due Diligence (CDD) measures, along with other screening and monitoring processes. These processes should utilize all publicly available resources and include comprehensive PEP and adverse media screening. At ComplyAdvantage, for example, we continually monitor for adverse media. Profiles are structured and accurately labeled using FATF-aligned categorization so that firms can, at a glance, understand what type of adverse media has been surfaced.
  • Suspicious Activity Reports: When reporting human trafficking activity in a suspicious acitivity report (SAR), firms should understand how to help the authorities in their investigation of traffickers by including key terms and information. The United States’ FINCEN SAR guidance, for example, requests the term “Advisory Human Trafficking” along with an explanation of why the reported activity is being considered suspicious.

Get Started Now

An effective AML solution should deal with risk quickly and help you stay in control of regulations.

0

2 Comments

Share your thoughts and start a conversation.

Leave a Reply

  • Rosa Manson says:

    As a Humanitarian Researcher, and looking into the differences between Human Trafficking and People Smuggling, but most of all how vast sums of money cross borders without being detected. Especially in countries where kidnapping and extortion is rife. (Such Eritrea). I hear these people get tortured and abused until these payments are made. I was wondering whether any had any information on this that could be worth researching (maybe similar to the Hawala System).

    0
    • Robert says:

      Hi Rosa, I’m afraid this is out of our expertise.

      I will point in the direction that may better suit your query:

      -https://www.transparency.org.uk/
      -https://www.amnesty.org.uk/
      -https://www.hrw.org/

      Apologies that we could not be of much help.

      0

Related articles:

AML Anti Money Laundering
June 22, 2014

What Is Anti-Money Laundering?

What is Anti-Money Laundering (AML) and why is it necessary? Over the past several decades, money…
Read More
Software with lines of code
July 3, 2018

Anti-Money Laundering Software

What Is Anti-Money Laundering Software? (And How Can it Help You?) According to UNODC, 2-5% of…
Read More
aml fines 2019
October 23, 2019

Anti-Money Laundering Fines 2019

Anti-Money Laundering Fines 2019 2019 is set to be a record year for global anti-money laundering…
Read More
November 6, 2019

Trade-Based Money Laundering

Trade-Based Money Laundering As anti-money laundering controls evolve, criminals find new ways to transform the…
Read More
cloud security aml
November 25, 2019

Cloud Security and AML

Cloud Security and AML As financial crime evolves, so do the methods financial institutions use to…
Read More
kyc aml
November 27, 2019

KYC vs AML

KYC vs AML - What Is The Difference? Anti-money laundering (AML) regulations are mandated by…
Read More
anti money laundering in hong kong
November 29, 2019

7 Tips For Fintechs to Comply With Anti-Money Laundering In Hong Kong

7 Tips For Fintechs to Comply With Anti-Money Laundering In Hong Kong Hong Kong is…
Read More
aml ctf regulation australia
December 2, 2019

7 Tips For Fintechs to Comply With Anti-Money Laundering In Australia

7 Tips For Fintechs to Comply With Anti-Money Laundering In Australia Australia is one of…
Read More
Landscape picture of Vancouver
January 7, 2020

Vancouver Money Laundering Model

Money Laundering: The Vancouver Model The Vancouver Model is a method of money laundering that…
Read More
Chess board in black and white to signify strategy
January 12, 2020

De-Risking And AML

De-Risking and AML: Strategies and Alternatives In an era of increased regulatory scrutiny and expectation,…
Read More
fatf travel rule aml
January 13, 2020

FATF Travel Rule

FATF Travel Rule: What You Need To Know The FATF Travel Rule is an update…
Read More
anti money laundering uk
February 24, 2020

AML in the UK

Anti Money Laundering Regulations In The UK The UK has a robust anti-money laundering framework…
Read More
Share:

To make sure you get a great experience on our website, we use cookies. To confirm you consent to this, please click below. Read more about our Cookie Policy

The cookie settings on this website are set to "allow cookies" to give you the best browsing experience possible. If you continue to use this website without changing your cookie settings or you click "Accept" below then you are consenting to this.

Close